Opinions Are Like Eyeballs...

Ok, we are enlisting the help of RHN readers/followers/stopper-byers to help Ed and I choose between two grays for our living/dining/giant room.  So we have it narrowed down to two grays (even though my father disagrees with the choices) pebble gray (medium gray) and Granite Gray (darker gray).  My dad picked out a different "gray", but his gray really isn't gray at all - it's a silver blue called Antique Silver. So, as much as I love my dad and value his opinion, we need (read:want) a gray-gray, not a so-so-blue-ish-gray. 


So, we ask: which gray??

Oh a lil mix up! 

We know which gray we think we like - even if dad doesn't.  The adjoining hallway is a light gray called Shining Silver.  Keep in mind, all trim will be white; the color of the hardwoods is natural and gorgeous; an we are modern-ish. 


So, friends, what's the verdict???  Dark Gray? Medium Gray? or Blue-Silver?